Please support our Reporters

The Opening Kickoff Of The 2026 Season In

Days
Hours
Minutes

Garnet Valley’s Brody Orr steps in to save the day for the Jags over Chester in District Semis

Written by: on Sunday, November 22nd, 2026. Follow Joseph Santoliquito on Twitter.

Garnet Valley’s Brody Orr

CHESTER, PA — They remember the tear streaks coming down the senior’s faces. They remember how badly they were beat. They even remember down to the very number of days (379) it had been since Garnet Valley lost to Chester in last year’s PIAA District 1 Class 5 quarterfinals.

Garnet Valley wanted revenge. No one on the Jaguars hid from that. Jags’ coach Eric Van Wyk even put it to his team, Saturday’s District 1 Class 5A semifinal playoff game with District No. 1 seed Chester was not only for themselves, but for last year’s seniors.

For a time, it looked as if Garnet Valley would lose its piece of revenge, after watching what appeared an overwhelming halftime lead dwindle to two points, when junior defensive back Brody Orr came from nowhere for a pick six, and then topped it by catching a touchdown pass off a flea-flicker for the Jags’ 41-22 victory.

Garnet Valley (12-1) will now face defending and undefeated District 1 Class 6A champion Springfield (13-0), at Springfield, for the PIAA District 1 Class 5A championship on Friday night at 7 p.m. Chester saw an amazing season end with a 13-1 record.

“Last year was motivation,” admitted Van Wyke, whose Jags were eliminated in the district playoffs by Chester, 38-7, last year. “We said during the week this game wasn’t just for ourselves, but for our seniors last year. Brody has been our playmaker. When we needed a play this year, he has been the one who stepped up. He has been very consistent.”

Chester looked like it would blow out Garnet Valley like the Clippers did the previous year, getting out to an 8-0 start. But the Jags tore off 24-straight unanswered points to go into halftime with a 24-8 lead.

Chester charged back with consecutive scores in the third quarter, both made possible by the Clippers’ sterling freshman tailback Sa’Mham Williams, whose 12-yard run made it 24-16 with 10:02 left in the third quarter, followed by his third touchdown of the game on a two-yard score with 9:22 left in the third—made possible by a Williams’ recovery on an inside kick.

That set the stage for Orr.

With Chester coming back at the Garnet Valley 36 looking for its third-straight and possible lead, Orr stepped in front of a Mekhi Wyche pass at the Jags’ 30 and went untouched for a 70-yard pick-six with 4:18 to play in the third.

With 5:53 left to play, Orr added some cushion by getting behind the Clippers’ secondary for a 28-yard halfback-option touchdown pass from Nick D’Antonio, putting Garnet Valley comfortably ahead 38-22.

“It was coaching, we talked about it all week when they run doubles (two receivers on each side) and they run four stops,” Orr said. “I recognized it and I knew I had to jump it. There was so much motivation from last year. I wasn’t a starter, I played in the second half. But everyone knew what they had to do today. We got it down.

“The (interception) set a fire. It was heartbreaking to watch the seniors walk off the field last year.”

The loss should not diminish the season Chester had. The Clippers won their fifth-straight Del-Val League and cultivated a future star in Williams, who rushed for a game-high 181 yards in 30 carries and three touchdowns, against a Jags’ defense solely designed to stop him.

Chester will be playing on a multi-million dollar, state-of-the-art athletic complex next year and return one of the top players in Southeastern Pennsylvania in Williams.

“Congratulations to Garnet Valley, they deserved to win, they were the better team today and they made the plays that they needed to make,” Chester coach Dennis Shaw said. “I’m still proud of my guys. We had a chance to put the game away early, and they were motivated by what happened last year. We fought back.

“I love what we did this year. I wanted more. The kids wanted more. (Williams) had another great game. He has three years ahead of him. We won’t sit around and cry about this. We beat their butts last year and they kicked our butts this year. I don’t want to take anything away from what Garnet Valley did. They’re well coached, they have great players. They were the better team.”

Scoring Summary

Garnet Valley (12-1) 0 24 7 10-41
Chester (12-1) 6 2 14 0-22

1st Quarter

C – Sa’Mham Williams 16 run (pass failed), 6:52

2nd Quarter

C – Safety, 8:20

GV – Roy Pomarico 8 run (Owen Zweier kick), 5:50

GV – Safety, 4:46

GV – Sebastian Cantu 2 run (Collin Schaller pass from Coltan Turner), 2:11

GV – Cantu 13 run (Zweier kick), :26

3rd Quarter

C – Williams 12 run (Jaden Flood pass from Mekhi Wyche), 10:02

C – Williams 2 run (run failed), 9:22

GV – Brody Orr 70 INT return (Zweier kick), 4:18

4th Quarter

GV – Orr 28 pass from Nick D’Antonio (Zweier kick), 5:53

GV – Zweier 36 FG, 1:55

Joseph Santoliquito is an award-winning sportswriter who has been covering high school football since 1992 and is the president of the Boxing Writers Association of America. Follow EasternPAFootball.com on Twitter @EPAFootball.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *